Cast iron or bimetallic radiator. What”s better

The energy efficiency and comfort of your home can be greatly impacted by the radiator type you choose. There are a few important things to compare between bimetallic and cast iron radiators. Heat retention and longevity have long been attributes of cast iron radiators. They are renowned for their timeless style, which can give any space a hint of retro charm.

Conversely, bimetallic radiators present cutting-edge developments in heating technology. Usually, they mix steel or aluminum with other metals to improve efficiency and heat conductivity. They are a popular option for energy-conscious homeowners because of their design, which frequently produces faster heating times and more precise temperature control.

Heat retention versus responsiveness is one of the main differences between these two radiator types. Although they take longer to heat up initially, cast iron radiators hold heat longer even after the heating system has been turned off. Over time, this may help to maintain a more constant room temperature and lessen the need for frequent adjustments.

Conversely, bimetallic radiators heat up more quickly and react quickly to thermostat settings changes. This responsiveness can be useful in situations where quick heating adjustments are required, like in areas that are only occasionally occupied or have a wide range of temperature preferences.

Each kind of radiator has advantages and disadvantages in terms of durability and upkeep. Cast iron radiators are renowned for their durability and longevity; with little upkeep, they can last for decades. They usually just need the occasional cleaning and repainting to keep their appearance intact, and they are less likely to corrode.

Bimetallic radiators, on the other hand, are less heavy and might be simpler to handle and install. Because they are made of more contemporary materials than traditional cast iron models, they are typically more corrosion resistant. However, the particular materials used and the level of manufacturing quality can affect how long they last.

In conclusion, your unique heating requirements, aesthetic preferences, and long-term maintenance concerns will ultimately determine which cast iron or bimetallic radiator is best for you. Whether you value contemporary efficiency and responsiveness over traditional durability and heat retention, knowing these distinctions can help you make the best choice for your house.

Features of each device

Learn about the features of heating batteries before you buy them.

Bimetallic radiators

These models came into being subsequent to the advancement of aluminum products. The quality and longevity of the original aluminum radiators used in central heating were the same. However, the strength of the batteries increased after the devices were modified and steel pipes were installed in them.

The two parts of a bimetallic model are internal and external:

• external – made of aluminum, which serves to transfer heat to the room;
• internal – it is based on steel through which the coolant circulates.

Additionally, this kind of battery can be semi-bimetallic. Only the vertical location’s channels in these subspecies are made of steel or copper. Although they have a 5–10% higher heat transfer, they should still be used carefully when using central heating.

Radiators made of cast iron material

In contrast to bimetallic radiators, cast iron radiators heat up slowly, so a large amount of water will be needed for optimal heat transfer. This explains why batteries have wide-diameter channels. Additionally, each section has two parallel channels. The need to enhance heat transfer is linked to this unique quality of cast iron radiators.

Feathers in between the channels of several standard models result in a 5–10% increase in heating efficiency.

Heat transfer indicators

The inertia of cast iron products is high. The room where the cast iron batteries are installed will take a lot longer to heat up because of its lengthy warming process. However, the material will take a while to cool down after it reaches operating temperature. This is particularly noticeable when there are heating system malfunctions or mishaps.

Convection and the infrared radiation from cast iron products cause heating. In addition to the air, the items in the room are also heated simultaneously. As a result, the average heating of a single cast iron radiator section varies between 100 and 160 W. These numbers relate to traditional models.

However, when bimetallic radiators are in use, their inertia is not as great. Firstly, the benefit is that warming up takes a lot less time. In a matter of minutes, the space where these heaters are placed warms up simultaneously. But the gadget also cools down rapidly when the heat source is turned off. Heating a single bimetallic battery section to a temperature of 150–180 W. The variations from cast iron products are negligible in this instance.

It is now important to contrast the operating pressure of the following two radiator types:

A cast iron object can endure up to twelve atmospheres. For the heating system in high-rise buildings, this indicator is ideal. The thin alloy of the cast iron base may rupture and crack in the event of a potential water hammer.

Two-metal. Twenty atmospheres of coolant pressure cannot penetrate the material. A few models are capable of 50 atmospheres. When there is hydraulic pressure, the battery’s internal component made of steel or copper can withstand the highest loads. In these devices, the only places that are deemed weak points are those where sections are connected. particularly if sealant, rather than gaskets or copper O-rings, was utilized to join them. Here, we are discussing inexpensive goods.

Coolant quality

Most of the time, the water that is supplied to the batteries is of poor quality and may include any of the following:

• chemical additives;
• dirt;
• small stones;
• rust;
• scale.

All of this wears down heating equipment. It is important to think about how these flaws impact two different kinds of radiators:

• Increased alkalinity and acidity do not affect cast iron radiators in any way. The batteries have fairly thick walls that can resist corrosion for a long time. It is removed with water when cleaning work is carried out in the summer. And abrasive elements can gradually wear away metal. However, again due to the thick walls, these changes are not noticeable.
• The chemically active composition of the coolant does little harm to the bimetallic radiator. However, when the water is drained, air appears in them, causing the metal core to rust.

In this instance, we can conclude that the corrosion resistance of cast iron heaters is higher.

The decision between bimetallic and cast iron radiators comes down to efficiency vs. durability. Because of their durability and capacity to hold heat, cast iron radiators are a great choice for older homes or spaces that need to stay warm for extended periods of time. Conversely, because of their lighter design and superior heat conduction, bimetallic radiators provide higher efficiency and faster heating. Your heating requirements, the kind of building, and long-term maintenance issues all play a major role in your decision. Knowing these distinctions will enable you to choose wisely, taking into account both your financial situation and your unique heating needs.

Temperature changes – which products are more resistant to them

The temperature in heating systems is also subject to variation. Sometimes the pipes are barely warm, but other times they burn your hands so much that you can’t even touch them.

Strong heating of the batteries determines their quality indicators if a weak temperature indicator is unable to distinguish between cast iron and bimetallic radiators.

Batteries made of cast iron can tolerate temperatures as high as 110 degrees. Bimetallic gadgets: up to 130°C. Although there isn’t much of a difference, the choice you make when installing a heating system in your house is yours. Another small detail about the bimetallic material is that it slightly cracks when heated. This noise is linked to variations in the linear expansion rates of steel and aluminum parts during heating and cooling.

Actual service life

Although the lifespan of the two types of radiators is unknown, there are rough estimates available:

1. Bimetallic radiators appeared on sale relatively recently. The warranty period for them from manufacturers is 10-15 years. Don’t think that products will last exactly as long as their warranty period. In reality, bimetal can last 25-30 years.
2. Cast iron products have a 10-25 year warranty. Since the material has been used for many years, you can be sure that on average it serves within 40 years, and sometimes even more. Some houses built in the 50s of the last century still have cast iron radiators.

At the moment, China, Russia, Germany, Italy, and Switzerland are the top producers of heating radiators in the building materials industry.

Appearance

Cast iron goods are now produced in a contemporary manner. However, some producers of cast iron radiators still favor the traditional methods. These kinds of products look like Soviet heaters. Sellers refer to this look as retro. Nonetheless, cast iron goods have changed for the better in the contemporary market. They are no longer as heavy, and their style is more appealing.

Standard types of bimetal radiators are produced. Only the feathers’ color and form can separate them.

There are a few things to consider when choosing a bimetallic or cast iron radiator for your house. For a very long time, cast iron radiators have been preferred due to their strength and capacity to hold heat. They are renowned for their timeless appearance and long-lasting, consistent, even heating. They are therefore perfect for those looking for a traditional aesthetic or for older homes.

Conversely, bimetallic radiators provide contemporary benefits. They are usually more responsive and have a higher heat output. In order to maximize heat transfer while preserving durability and corrosion resistance, bimetallic construction combines different metals. In the long run, this may lead to shorter heating times and possibly cheaper energy costs.

Ultimately, which of these two options you choose will depend on your own requirements and tastes. Cast iron radiators might be a better option if you value classic style and even heat distribution. Although they can be heavier and take longer to heat up initially, they require less upkeep. Bimetallic radiators are a strong substitute for individuals who value energy economy and quick heating response.

In the end, the choice should take into account elements like the size of the area you’re heating, your spending limit, and the general design of your house. You can choose the best type of radiator for your needs and lifestyle by carefully considering these factors, as each type has advantages.

Video on the topic

Is it necessary to change old cast iron batteries to new ones?

The main disadvantages of cast iron radiators!

Than aluminum radiators are better than cast -iron? Plumber answered

Steel panel radiator or sectional bimetallic radiator? What"s better?

Which battery is better, cast iron, steel, aluminum or bimetal??

Cast iron or bimetallic? Which to choose?

The WARMEST BATTERIES for your home / How to choose heating radiators