What is the difference between a suspended ceiling and a suspended ceiling??

The terms "drop ceiling" and "suspended ceiling" are frequently used when remodeling or updating a space. They seem so similar that it’s easy to become confused, but there are some significant differences between them that, depending on your needs and preferences, may influence your decision.

A suspended ceiling is one that is suspended below a room’s main structural ceiling. Typically, tiles or panels are supported by a metal or other material framework. This arrangement leaves a gap between the old and new ceiling, perfect for concealing ductwork, plumbing, or wiring.

Conversely, a drop ceiling is a kind of suspended ceiling in which the panels or tiles are made especially so that they "drop" into the grid structure. This more particular style—where tiles are readily removable and replaceable, making maintenance simple—is commonly referred to as a "drop ceiling."

Each kind of ceiling has advantages and disadvantages. Suspended ceilings can be customized with various materials and are an excellent way to hide infrastructure. Drop ceilings are especially useful in areas where access to concealed systems is needed frequently because of their easily removable panels. Gaining an understanding of these distinctions will enable you to choose wisely for your upcoming undertaking.

Why this particular finishing option?

Several apartment owners who have chosen to install one of the ceiling types under consideration describe their decision as simply beautiful. But this explanation falls short of explaining why new designs for ceiling spaces are so popular with homeowners.

Actually, this finishing technique permits:

  • hide all ceiling flaws: cracks, chips, panel joints, slope, etc.d.;
  • do not carry out labor-intensive and dirty work to level the ceiling surface;
  • hide communications (various cables) running on top of the apartment;
  • increase the level of noise insulation;
  • additionally insulate the room;
  • create more comfortable living conditions;
  • bring to life the most fantastic ideas of designers.

Design differences

You must first comprehend how a stretch ceiling and a suspended ceiling differ in terms of design before comparing the functional, financial, and aesthetic aspects of two ceiling space design systems. You’ll be able to understand the compared parameters more clearly as a result.

The fastening system is the primary distinction between a suspended ceiling and a suspended ceiling. Tension fabric, as the name suggests, is stretched between baguettes that are fixed along the walls’ perimeter. The baguettes are attached to the tension fabric.

Suspended ceilings are created by mounting plasterboard sheets to a stiff suspended frame (which may also be slatted), which is fastened to the ceiling and the walls simultaneously using specialized hangers.

Three additional distinctions can be made based on the definitions given above:

  1. the suspended ceiling has a hard surface; under certain conditions, a suspended ceiling can sag significantly, for example, when water gets in from the roof or from neighbors above;
  2. plasterboard, which is used to cover the suspended ceiling frame, can withstand various mechanical loads: shocks, scratches, cuts, etc.d., PVC film or synthetic fabric (polyester) can tear from a light touch of a sharp object;
  3. The damaged surface of a suspended ceiling can be easily repaired, up to the replacement of a separate element; for a tension ceiling, the entire panel must be replaced completely.

In order to dispel any ambiguity surrounding suspended ceilings, we will distinguish between two popular styles in this post: the conventional drop ceiling and the contemporary grid ceiling. Both styles have different installation and design processes, even though they both hang from the main ceiling to hide wires and ducts. Knowing these distinctions will assist you in selecting the best solution for your area, whether you’re updating an office or remodeling your house.

Comparative analysis

The only way to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of installing a suspended or suspended ceiling in an apartment is to compare the key features of the two systems under consideration.

Degree of installation complexity

When comparing the complexity of the work required to install the two types of ceilings, a paradoxical situation occurs: the work can be completed independently, but only with a team (at least two people) who have a basic understanding of how to use power tools (hammer and screwdriver). The complex structure of the suspended ceiling makes it difficult to apply markings to the ceiling space’s surface. Stretching PVC or polyester film onto baguettes is simpler, but it is not a task that should be left to an amateur because there is a significant chance of fabric damage.

Speed of work completion

Installing a suspended ceiling takes two to four days; it can be done in one working day. Stretch ceiling installation can take up to two days, while suspended ceiling installation can take ten days, if the design becomes more complex (has more levels).

Cleanliness in the apartment during installation

According to every publication, there is a lot of dirt during the installation of a suspended ceiling, but very little during the stretch ceiling installation. This leads one to the conclusion that the tension structure is greatly advantageous in this regard. Is that correct?

In fact, the weight of the dust and dirt produced when working with suspended ceilings versus plasterboard is higher with the former. However, the inferences made from this are not totally accurate.

Dust from drilling holes in the wall from the trellis is difficult, if not impossible, to remove, so glued walls in both situations need to be covered with plastic film regardless of the amount of dust present.

Additionally, when stretching the film and installing a suspended ceiling, the entire furniture must be taken out of the room. Even with polyethylene covering it, dust particles will still manage to find their way onto the furniture. Will need to tidy up. Simply put, there will be a big layer in one scenario and a small layer in the other. Thus, equality in this case, in our opinion.

Durability

The service life of the ceiling is a crucial factor to consider when selecting the type. PVC film manufacturers state in their guidelines that the canvas can last over 20 years with the right maintenance.

This isn’t as easy as that. It is true that a thicker, more costly film can last the designated amount of time while sacrificing a little bit of its aesthetic appeal. After 8 to 9 years of use, materials in the average price range that are commonly used start to lose their original appearance. It is necessary to replace such a ceiling 14–16 years after installation.

The manufacturer has not specified a service life for GKL; ceilings of this type can endure for 20–30 years. There is one more issue, though. Every seven to eight years, they must be repainted. It’s difficult to determine which is preferable: frequent surface renewal with a very long service life or trouble-free maintenance over an extended period of time. The customer has discretion over this decision.

Strength

One of the few parameters where one of the ceiling systems has a clear advantage over the other is the strength indicator. Unlike gypsum board, which can tolerate heavy mechanical loads, stretch ceilings are incredibly vulnerable to any mechanical stress and will eventually tear.

Care

It is also quite easy to maintain a stretched sheath and the suspension structure. Wet cleaning a few times a year is sufficient. Avoid trying to remove tough stains on the film by yourself as you might end up with stains that are hard to get rid of.

For this kind of work, there are specialist cleaning companies. Ultimately, gypsum plasterboard stains that are difficult to remove can be easily painted over. It is also challenging to choose one of the ceiling finishing systems in this situation.

Moisture resistance

Installation of stretched PVC film in any damp room (kitchen, bathroom) is possible; a suspended structure composed of gypsum plasterboard is resistant to moisture (water and steam). The ability of the film ceiling to hold onto water when it flows from above—it can easily hold up to 100 liters—is another benefit that almost all observers mention.

They fail to consider the possibility, though, that water could result in a short circuit in the lighting system’s electrical wiring. Water cannot put out the burning wires in this situation, and an apartment fire is possible. It’s hard to say which is more crucial in this situation: keeping the apartment safe from flooding or the possibility of fire.

Loss of room height

At least 5 cm is "stolen" from the room by either choice. Numerous articles state that the frame reduces the ceiling by 10 to 20 centimeters, but they don’t say why. In actuality, the total 5 cm for a stretch ceiling is obtained by adding the plasterboard thickness, the ceiling profile height (PS), and the minimum suspension length.

Similar instructions apply to suspended ceilings; the baguette must be installed a minimum of 3.5 cm below the planned height; however, they do not specify how to use an electric or hammer drill to drill holes for dowels. This is because the size of the cartridge will cause the baguette to be installed 1.5 cm below the intended height.

Fire resistance

Both PVC and plasterboard are not conducive to open combustion; however, PVC releases toxic substances at high temperatures while gypsum remains completely safe.

Aesthetic perception

Stretch ceilings offer a greater variety of options for interior design solutions. The stretched fabric’s surface may be:

  • glossy;
  • semi-gloss;
  • matte;
  • under velvet;
  • under the skin, etc.d.

There are 100 distinct colors. The surface can be decorated with a variety of drawings, including a picture of the apartment’s owner. Practically speaking, the designer’s creativity is not constrained by such a ceiling.

There are fewer options for putting design concepts into practice when there is a suspended ceiling. Here, you can play around with the lighting, surface color, and ceiling heights. These ceilings appear equally striking.

It is hard to favor one system over another. Everything is based on personal preference.

Which is cheaper?

In many online articles, authors determine which is cheaper: suspended ceilings or suspended or suspended ceilings, but their conclusions are not entirely accurate. They only compare the costs of one square meter of PVC sheet and plasterboard, for whatever reason.

There is a claim that, when material costs are factored in, plasterboard ceilings are roughly twice as expensive as stretch ceilings (between 100 and 120 rubles versus 200 and 250 rubles). However, they overlook a crucial detail: the price of the frame, finishing supplies, paint, and other materials, measured per square meter, is five times higher than the price of gypsum boards.

It turns out that the family budget needs to be used to pay 600–700 rubles for 1 m 2 of suspended structure. The cost will soar to 2500–3000 rubles/m2 if you engage a professional team; this includes not just assembling the frame and covering it with gypsum boards, but also puttying seams, sealing surfaces, priming, and painting with water-based paint.

One meter square of stretch ceiling can cost between 700 and 2,000 rubles per square meter. The price per square meter when using exclusive fabric can be as high as 7,000 rubles.

When comparing average-priced materials and labor, a suspended ceiling is significantly more costly. Assembling the frame and finishing the gypsum board yourself will save you money. However, because materials are expensive, the final costs will differ slightly.

In conclusion, if finishing the ceiling is your top priority financially, you should go with a tension structure.

Suspended Ceiling A suspended ceiling is a secondary ceiling that hangs below the main ceiling. It’s often used to hide pipes, ducts, and wires, providing easy access for maintenance. It also helps with soundproofing and insulation.
Drop Ceiling A drop ceiling is essentially the same as a suspended ceiling. It’s a common term used interchangeably, referring to the ceiling that drops down from the main ceiling. It also provides a space for utilities and helps with acoustics and aesthetics.
Key Difference There is no real difference between a suspended ceiling and a drop ceiling; they are different names for the same concept. Both terms describe a ceiling that hangs below the main structural ceiling.

It’s critical to comprehend the differences between a suspended ceiling and a drop ceiling when selecting ceiling types for your area. Despite the fact that the terms are frequently used synonymously, depending on the situation, they may sometimes refer to slightly different ideas.

Generally speaking, a suspended ceiling is one that is suspended from a building’s main structure by means of a system of metal tracks. With this arrangement, you can conceal ducts, wiring, and other utilities in the space created between the old and new ceilings. The fact that it makes these systems easily accessible makes it a popular option for commercial spaces.

In contrast, a drop ceiling is a kind of suspended ceiling in which the tiles or panels are arranged according to a grid system. Because of its simplicity of installation and visual appeal, this kind of ceiling is frequently chosen. In terms of design, drop ceilings can be a little more adaptable, providing a range of finishes and styles to accommodate various tastes.

The final decision between these ceiling styles will be based on your own requirements and tastes. You can choose the best ceiling for your space by knowing the differences between suspended and drop ceilings, regardless of whether you value appearance, functionality, or a mix of the two.

Video on the topic

Stretch or plasterboard, which ceiling is better?? Info from TOPs

Fabric stretch ceiling Descor. Advantages and disadvantages.

Which ceiling is better, fabric or PVC

10 rules for choosing stretch ceilings 🔴 Fabric or PVC stretch ceilings? Advantages and disadvantages

Types of suspended ceilings.Which ceiling is better?

What factor is most important for you when choosing materials for building a house??
Share to friends
Timur Kiselev

Professional builder with 15 years of experience. I know everything about the construction of houses, cottages, bathhouses and other buildings. I will be happy to share my knowledge and experience with you.

Rate author
StroyArsenal62.com
Add a comment