What is the difference between MDF and laminated chipboard and which is better??

Two common choices for materials for building or home remodeling projects are laminated chipboard and MDF (medium-density fiberboard). In cabinetry, furniture construction, and other woodworking applications, both materials are frequently utilized. However, how can you determine which one is best for your project?

Making an informed choice requires an understanding of the distinctions between MDF and laminated chipboard. Every material has a unique set of properties, benefits, and drawbacks. We will examine the differences between these two materials in this post and assist you in deciding which would be a better fit for your requirements.

We will go over every important detail you should think about, from their cost and durability to their composition and manufacturing process. Selecting the appropriate material for any woodworking task, such as building durable furniture or installing kitchen cabinets, can be made easier by understanding the advantages and disadvantages of MDF and laminated chipboard.

So let’s get into the specifics and see what distinguishes laminated chipboard from MDF so you can decide which is more appropriate for your upcoming project.

What it is

The relevant materials are comparable. However, despite using similar raw materials, they differ greatly in many ways, starting with the production stage.

laminated chipboard

Laminated chipboard, to put it simply, is a composite material made of chipboard sheets that have been laminated. Initially, sawdust, shavings, and inferior wood (boughs, firewood, and short scraps of industrial wood) that are turned into chips are used to make chipboard. The resultant slab has decoration on its surface. Two technologies can be used to accomplish this.

1. By layering the exterior. The following order is followed when performing operations:

1. paper is glued to the base of the plate in 1 or 2 layers;
2. a film of a mixture of resins is applied;
3. using a press, a pattern imitating natural wood is squeezed out on paper or a decorative film with a finished texture is glued;
4. under pressure at high temperatures, a protective film of melamine is attached to the surface of the slab, forming a durable laminated coating.

2. By gluing—a process known as laminating—the same film onto a plate by pressing it without using a high temperature.

The first example features a traditional laminated chipboard, while the second is a miserable imitation with just one benefit—the inexpensive material.

The primary drawback of the product is its binder, formaldehyde resin, which when used releases toxic substances.

MDF

MDF is a common acronym for fine fraction. However, this represents the Russian interpretation of the material’s English name (MDF, or medium density fiberboard; literally translated: medium density fiberboard).

Made from electronic chips, which

• grinds to the size of small crumbs;
• cleaned with superheated (temperature over 100 o C) steam supplied under pressure;
• it is ground to the state of fibers on a defiber (abrasive stone);
• dried up to 9%;
• separated (larger fraction is screened out);
• heated and then pressed under high pressure.

Strong heating causes lignin, a natural resin, to emerge from the wood, binding the fibers together into a slab.

• E0 is a safe material that uses lignin;
• E1 – permitted material (urea resins modified with melamine, emitting formaldehyde in small quantities);
• E2 – not recommended for use in homes, offices and apartments (phenol-formaldehyde alcohol-containing resins are used).

The MDF is finally cooled, sanded to match veneer, PVC film, or natural wood, and polished in preparation for enamel painting. The result is a material that, in most cases, is even better than natural wood in terms of performance.

As a point of reference, MDF that is 4 mm thick can occasionally be categorized as fiberboard. It’s not accurate. These are distinct materials.

Advantages and disadvantages

Each of the materials under comparison has unique strengths and weaknesses based on their production characteristics.

laminated chipboard

Experts point out that laminated chipboard has the following benefits:

• good bending strength (from 10 to 25 MPa) and tensile strength (0.2-0.5 MPa), allowing to withstand severe static loads, as evidenced by shelves in cabinets and kitchen units;
• durability – service life from 10 to 50 years (depending on operating conditions);
• variety of laminating film decors, both in color and texture. The most common surfaces are alder, beech, oak, and ash;
• simple processing – a jigsaw and drill will perform any operation. You can cut the required dimensions manually using a fine-tooth file;
• budget cost – the material itself and furniture made from it are available to families with low incomes;
• Easy care – just wipe with a damp cloth;
• resistance to temperature fluctuations and changes in humidity – the glued laminated film does not allow the chipboard to change its linear dimensions;
• acceptable indicators of heat and sound insulation;
• resistance to fungus and mold – they do not multiply on the material.

Additionally, there are drawbacks. Among the noteworthy ones are:

• the strength of the chipboard layer raises questions. For example, clogged choppers hold the load well. But the screws that are screwed in come out with the “meat” when a small force is applied parallel to the plane of the slab. This applies not only to wall decoration, but also to furniture – hinges screwed with self-tapping screws lose their rigidity over time. Attempts to tighten fasteners deeper or replace them with longer hardware give a short-term positive effect. It is possible to restore the original parameters, but it is difficult. Not every craftsman manages to do this, even those who know well not only theory, but also practice;
• the appearance, despite the variety of designs, raises questions – inexpensive material is immediately visible;
• low resistance to moisture in direct contact – deformation processes develop, which appear on the surface in the form of swellings and other irregularities. This is especially noticeable on bathroom furniture: it is almost impossible to perfectly seal joints and edges;

• cannot be milled, so the surface is always flat. Fans of concave or convex doors in cabinets and kitchen units need to forget about their attachment to unusual shapes;
• the risk of chipping due to inattentive processing (even in a shop, when cutting using professional equipment, light chips appear, which is clearly visible in the picture);

• if the integrity of the protective film is damaged, as well as on sections, formaldehyde may evaporate when the temperature rises.

MDF

MDF offers comparable benefits and drawbacks. However, there are also distinctions. Among the benefits are:

• high density, allowing the use of self-tapping screws for fastening;
• durability – products last more than half a century;
• resistance to mechanical damage;
• easy processing – you don’t have to worry about chipping when processing the material. You can cut with any tool suitable for sawing wood;
• large selection of colors;
• varied design, thanks to several types of surface decoration: painting, gluing laminating film or natural veneer;
• the possibility of complex surface milling – you can create any relief;
• tolerates short-term contact with liquids without consequences for the structure of the material – deformation processes do not develop;
• versatility — used indoors for finishing works, manufacturing furniture, doors;
• goes well with decorative inserts made of metal and glass;
• is environmentally friendly — does not contain allergens and formaldehyde resins;
• practically does not react to changes in humidity and temperature;
• the surface is uniform, even and smooth (it is well sanded and polished);
• technical and operational characteristics are similar to natural wood at a lower price.

A further benefit that many overlook is the capacity to create materials in a range of thicknesses, from 4.0 mm (similar to fiberboard) to 22.0 mm.

• high price due to the fact that there is practically no domestic production in Russia — it has to be imported.

Comparison of characteristics

The benefits and drawbacks already allow for the initial conclusions to be made. A comparative examination of the primary technical and operational indicators offers a comprehensive understanding of the differences between MDF and laminated chipboard.

• cost;
• strength;
• durability;
• appearance (design);
• moisture resistance;
• flammability class;
• environmental friendliness;
• processing difficulties;
• scope of application.

Cost. The cost factor is always the primary consideration when comparing comparable building materials. MDF falls short in this aspect because it costs 1.5–2.5 times as much as its rival. The higher density and strength account for the high cost.

Furthermore, the type of surface decor affects the price factor: PVC film or plastic covers panels at the lowest cost, enamel painting entails higher costs, and natural wood veneer is the most expensive option. The price difference is also notable in the veneered product segment. Everything is dependent on the kind of wood used to make the facing material.

Chipboard is less expensive. The indicator in question indicates that it has a significant advantage over comparable building materials.

Conclusion: Laminated particle board clearly has an advantage in terms of price characteristics.

Power. The strength criterion is usually taken into account a little later because it has less of an impact on the selection of building materials. however not with regard to furniture sets. Resistance to both static and dynamic mechanical loads is crucial in this situation. In particular, hinges and shelf-supporting fittings are fasteners. Laminated chipboard is significantly less than MDF (density 720-870 kg/m3) in this component because of its loose structure and low density (only 350-650 kg/m3).

As a result, "disposable" material became another term for particle board among furniture makers and builders. It is true that even with flawless disassembly and reassembling, it can be difficult to take apart a particle board building structure and put it back together again because the hardware will either hold loosely or the holes will crumble. Without a 100% guarantee, you will also need to apply a sawdust and epoxy resin mixture to the fastening points.

MDF is just as strong as natural wood and can withstand several assembly and disassembly cycles.

In conclusion, MDF is significantly stronger than chipboard.

Lifespan. Chipboard-made medications are particularly vulnerable at the wall’s attachment points, around loops, and where the shelves are fastened. Furthermore, accidental contact with water drastically lowers the wood-fiber plate’s operational resource. Consequently, the material has a long run at the time of operation: from a year (bathroom shelves) to fifty years. MDF has a 50-year shelf life and none of the aforementioned drawbacks.

In summary, MDF outlasts chipboard in terms of durability.

Look. When comparing the materials’ appearance, the author encountered forum users who had the exact opposite opinion. The information published on other websites about a particular subject mirrored this state of affairs. While some design writers favor MDF, others favor laminated chipboard. Nonetheless, the site’s editors all agree that MDF has an advantage because of veneer and the capacity to mill the surface, giving the slab’s front side a lovely relief.

In conclusion, MDF has advantages due to its beautiful surface shapes that mimic wood carving and veneer and enhance the appearance of natural wood.

Classification of flammability. Even with the addition of fire retardants, both materials burn. But MDF loses because hot objects cause it to light up faster.

In conclusion, using materials in areas that are at risk of fire is not advised because they will burn. Laminated chipboard does, in fact, have one small benefit: it burns easily at high temperatures or over open flames.

Resistance to moisture. MDF can withstand moisture better. Because of its high density and substantial natural resin content, the material can get wet without swelling. Water does not frighten well-glued (note: well-glued and with good sidewall processing) chipboards with laminating film.

However, even the smallest tear to the protective film causes the material to get wet and swell, which results in a 25–30% increase in volume. The material gets deformed, and it doesn’t get better when it dries.

In conclusion, MDF has a slight advantage over other materials in terms of moisture resistance.

Ecological purity. Laminated chipboard loses to its competitor because formaldehyde resin, which is used in its production, releases harmful substances, particularly when room temperature rises. Emission comes from damaged protective film and machined ends. MDF is free of any dangerous materials.

In conclusion, laminated chipboard is not as environmentally friendly as its rival. It makes sense that Europe and Japan are taking precautions: they restrict the use of laminated chipboard in kindergartens and children’s rooms and add unique additives to formaldehyde resin that lessen the release of dangerous substances.

Complicated processing. Builders and furniture makers alike are aware of chipboard’s brittleness. With laminated boards, the same issue persists. As a result, you must cut carefully to avoid getting the outcome seen in the image. These are not issues with MDF. Furthermore, wood fiber boards (MDF) have a millable surface, whereas laminated chipboards cannot.

In summary, MDF clearly has an advantage in processing complexity.

Application range. MDF has a wider range of applications when it comes to operational and technical indicators. But the material’s high cost restricts its uses (furniture, countertop, kitchen apron, door leaf and frame, trim). Laminated chipboard is therefore advantageous in practice because it is used for furniture, walls, floors, and roofs.

In conclusion, while laminated chipboard is superior in practice, MDF has an advantage in theory. The site editors therefore made the decision not to assess the criterion.

We have compiled the comparison results in Table 1 to make the differences between the materials crystal clear.

Table 1: Comparative analysis results in numerical form.

Materials	Score
Criteria	Laminated chipboard	MDF
Cost	5	2.5
Strength	3.5	5
Durability	4	4.5
Appearance (design)	3.5	5
Moisture resistance	1	3
Flammability	3	2
Environmental friendliness	3.5	5
Difficulty of processing	3.5	5
Scope	no rating	no rating
Average rating	3.375	4

Understanding the main benefits and distinctions between laminated chipboard and MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard) is crucial when making this decision for your building or remodeling project. Because of its longevity and smooth finish, MDF is a great material for intricate woodworking and painting. On the other hand, laminated chipboard—which is made of wood chips and a resin binder—is more reasonably priced and frequently utilized for cabinetry and furniture with pre-finished surfaces. The decision between the two will rely on the particular requirements of your project, your financial constraints, and the desired finish. Laminated chipboard offers cost-effective versatility, while MDF offers a premium feel.

How to distinguish MDF from laminated chipboard

The materials differ in terms of feel, appearance, and smell in addition to their technical and financial attributes. Consequently, MDF:

• most often has a milled surface, which is excluded from laminated chipboard;
• dense, uniform end with fine grain.

Laminated chipboard and MDF differ from one another in another way: the former has a smooth cut edge.

Laminated chipboard is distinguished by the following features:

• the presence of large fragments of wood (chips);
• loose structure with voids;
• a specific smell that cannot be confused with anything else if you have worked with laminated chipboard at least once.

The end provides the simplest means of material differentiation. The material’s structure is depicted in the picture below. It cannot be misunderstood.

Criteria	MDF	Laminated Chipboard
Material	Made from wood fibers compressed with resin	Made from wood chips and resin, covered with a laminate layer
Strength	Stronger and more durable	Less strong, can be more prone to damage
Surface	Smooth and easy to paint or veneer	Pre-finished with a laminate, less customizable
Cost	Generally more expensive	Typically cheaper
Uses	Ideal for furniture and cabinetry	Commonly used for shelves and low-cost furniture
Moisture Resistance	More resistant to moisture	Can swell or warp if exposed to water

It is essential to comprehend the distinctions between laminated chipboard and medium density fiberboard (MDF) when undertaking building and remodeling projects. For intricate woodworking and cabinetry, MDF is the perfect material because it has a smoother finish and is more manageable. Its homogeneous composition guarantees that it won’t break or splinter easily.

Conversely, laminated chipboard is typically less expensive and has a pre-finished surface, which means that less finishing work is required. It’s a sensible option for large-scale applications and projects on a tight budget when aesthetics are not the main priority.

Which material is superior ultimately comes down to your own priorities and needs. MDF can be a better option if accuracy and a superior finish are important to you. However, laminated chipboard might be a better option if price and convenience are your main priorities.

You can select the material that best suits your needs and the specifications of your project by weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each. Both MDF and laminated chipboard have advantages over the other and can help achieve desirable results when building or renovating.

Video on the topic

MDF or chipboard facades?

What is the difference between MDF and laminated chipboard?

MDF or laminated chipboard: what to choose, “DaVita-furniture”

Now you know about the most durable material for the kitchen. 24 hours underwater. PLYWOOD, laminated chipboard and MDF

What is the difference between MDF and chipboard?

Differences between Uvadrev and Egger chipboards? The difference between laminated chipboard and MDF? What is edge?

MDF or chipboard which is better? Comparing the main indicators

Chipboard or MDF? What to choose when making furniture?